Case definitions
Before a condition can be counted, someone has to decide what counts as having it. That decision is the case definition, and there is seldom only one reasonable choice. Diabetes shows the problem well. A health survey can identify it in at least four ways.
- The respondent says a doctor has diagnosed it.
- The respondent takes insulin or another glucose-lowering medicine.
- A blood test finds glycated hemoglobin (HbA1c) at or above 6.5 percent.
- A fasting blood test finds plasma glucose at or above 126 milligrams per deciliter.
Each of the four picks out a somewhat different group. Some adults with a diagnosis have laboratory readings under both thresholds because their treatment is working. Others meet a threshold and have never been told. The two laboratory tests also disagree with each other, so adding or dropping one changes the count.
A definition based on diagnosis alone counts those who know they have the condition, and one that accepts any of the four counts the most. The two answer different questions. Estimates built on different definitions cannot be compared as though they measured one thing. A trend can mislead in the same way when the definition changed partway through.
The choice is also limited by what was measured. In a national survey, fasting glucose is measured only in the respondents asked to fast, and that subsample has its own weights and wider margins of uncertainty.
The firm states the definition before the analysis begins. The main estimate is then reported under each reasonable alternative, with a note of how far it moves.
